For doctors · Growth

Why patients don't book doctors through apps, and what that means for your practice

A patient in a tier-two city waited fifty minutes at a dermatologist, went home, found half a dozen booking apps, and asked Reddit why nobody uses them. The answers are short and brutal. They are also a free market-research report for any doctor deciding where their patients should come from.

Ashwin Kumar, Founder, Swasthy
10 October 2026 · Updated 13 November 2026 · 8 min read

What patients said

The booking does not reach the clinic. "Those apps don't work. Period. Try booking an appointment through that app. Your doctor's office will have no record of that appointment." (u/desichica, r/AskIndia, October 2025.) A doctor confirmed the other side of it: "out of 500+ patients, <10 have paid directly on Practo because of extremely low trust in Practo advertised schedule vs Doctor's actual availability" (u/azhar2005, r/DoctorsofIndia, October 2024).

Walking in is simpler. "Why use practo when I can directly book at the hospital through their app or via call? Heck i can just walk in, pay for the appointment and get seen on the same day without any fuss?" (u/forelsketparadise1.)

The instant consult is a lottery. A patient paid ₹629 expecting to choose a senior doctor and schedule a call: "No Scheduling: I was connected instantly to a doctor. I had no choice in the matter." The doctor "read" a 22-page report in eighty seconds (u/HarMaidanFateh, r/india, December 2025, 379 upvotes). Another: "I specifically asked for a gastro doc and they provided me a consultation with a psychologist."

The price is marked up. "Direct booking came to 800rs where as the Practo app was showing me 1200 to book a slot ... a difference of 50% is too much." (u/22RMB.) A doctor in the same thread explained why: "practo takes 50% of the dr fees + to be visible on practo, I pay 23k per month. That's why alot of Dr keep raised fee on practo."

The reviews are filtered. "The review on doctors on Practo CAN NOT be trusted as they publish a feedback only after approval of the doctor." (u/Creepy-Frosting-2290.)

They cannot tell who is good. "Most of patient they don't now which doctor is highly qualified for their Particular disease." (u/TypicalYou8311.) And from the other thread: "The results on practo are not filterable by experience or highest qualification ... just the top payers on top." (u/Adventurous-Parsnip3.)

And one good one. "I had booked a call with a dentist during covid lockdown. My jaw had swelled up massively ... She had a look on video call, and asked if I can come to her clinic immediately. It was far. So then she took the pains of coming to a clinic near my location herself." (u/whatever4100.) Worth remembering: the good experience was a good doctor, found through an app, acting like a good doctor.

What it means for your practice

Three things, if you run or plan to run a clinic.

  1. The booking channel has to be yours or reliable, and most are neither. If a patient books through a listing and arrives to find no record, they blame you, not the app. The doctors in these threads fixed it the obvious way: use the listing for first contact, then move the patient to a direct booking. "That way patient still pays same ~500 INR but full amount goes to the practice." (u/thefoxtor, 128 upvotes.)
  2. Trust is built in the room, and spent online. Patients cannot read qualifications off a marketplace, so they rely on the only signals left: the price, the reviews, and whether the last visit went well. A clinic that runs on time and explains clearly is doing more for its online reputation than any paid placement. Our notes on what the NMC lets you do are in how to get more patients.
  3. The instant-consult lottery is a warning about any platform you join. If patients are matched at random and routed to whoever is free regardless of specialty, the doctor on the other end is set up to fail, and the patient who paid ₹629 writes the thread above. Before you take cases from any platform, ask how it matches a case to a doctor.

What a platform owes the patient

We read these threads as a list of promises a platform has to keep, so here are ours, in public.

  • One price, shown before you pay, no markup on the doctor's fee. A consultation on Swasthy costs the patient one flat fee, shown before you pay, and a follow-up within fourteen days with the same doctor costs less. That is the whole price.
  • A real, verified doctor, matched to the case. Every doctor's registration is verified before their first case. A case is matched by specialty and availability, not assigned at random, and the doctor's name and registration number are on the prescription.
  • A doctor who has read the case. The doctor opens the case with time to read it, so they are not reading twenty-two pages in eighty seconds. They are deciding.
  • A signed prescription, every time. Every prescription carries the doctor's name, qualification and registration number, as the guidelines require.
  • Nothing reaches the patient unsigned. The doctor owns the decision. That is the rule the Telemedicine Practice Guidelines set, and the rule we built around.

If you are a doctor and that is the kind of platform you want behind your name, register interest and we will call you within 48 hours.

Checking the complaints against the record

Reddit is where people vent, so we checked each complaint against something with a name on it.

  • "Connected instantly, no choice." That is how the product is designed. Practo's consumer FAQ for online consultations: "Once payment is made, we alert our panel of verified, high-quality doctors and allocate a doctor to your consultation." The patient is not choosing; the platform is allocating, after payment.
  • "₹629 for a doctor whose fee is ₹199." A reviewer on Trustpilot described exactly that: paying ₹629 for a consultation with a doctor whose own listed fee on the app was ₹199. Anonymous, but a second, independent account of the same gap.
  • "The fee is higher through the app." Here the record cuts both ways, and we say so. Practo's Prime FAQ states that the patient pays the doctor's consultation fee and that it "is the same as for walk-in patients", with no booking charge to the patient. The r/india poster saw ₹1,200 on the app against ₹800 direct, and a doctor in the same thread explained why that happens even when the rule is kept: doctors "keep raised fee on practo" to cover what the listing costs them. Both can be true. The fee on the app is the fee the doctor set for the app.
  • "The booking never reached the clinic." On 25 October 2024 the local-search analyst Mike Blumenthal documented booking buttons appearing on healthcare Google profiles "with or without approval of the business", named Practo among the providers, and quoted a practice that was double-booked by appointments it never agreed to take. A booking made through a button the clinic did not set up is a booking the clinic may not see.
  • "Doctors pay to be visible." Practo's own Prime FAQ confirms it charges the clinic "a one time technology fee per patient the first time you book". A kidney transplant surgeon, Dr Vinay Rai, told Medical Dialogues in November 2024 he was being charged "around Rs 350-450 as a connection fee" when a patient merely called to ask about him. The patient who feels the price is marked up and the doctor who feels squeezed are describing the same rupees.
  • "Reviews only go up with the doctor's approval." We found no ruling or regulator's finding on this, only repeated Trustpilot accounts of reviews held, redacted or removed. Treat it as unproven. It is still what patients believe, which is what matters for trust.

Questions doctors ask

Why don't patients use doctor booking apps in India?

The complaints are consistent: the booking did not reach the clinic, the instant consultation matched them with a random doctor, the app's price was higher than the clinic's, and the reviews looked curated. Trust, not technology, is what they say is missing.

Does it matter to a doctor where patients book?

Yes. A booking that never arrives costs you the slot and the patient's trust, a markup makes you look expensive, and a review you cannot answer follows you. Where your patients come from shapes what they think of you before you meet.

What should a doctor check before joining a platform?

Whether the patient sees one price before paying, whether bookings reliably reach you, whether you can answer reviews, and whose name goes on the prescription. If any answer is vague, so is the platform.

Sources

  • u/InternationalAsk1924, "Why do people don't use apps like practo to book appointments?", r/AskIndia, October 2025. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskIndia/comments/1nwv2ix/
  • u/HarMaidanFateh, "Practo is a scam", r/india, December 2025 (379 upvotes, 61 comments). https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1q10czm/
  • u/azhar2005, "Latest scam from Practo", r/DoctorsofIndia, October 2024. https://www.reddit.com/r/DoctorsofIndia/comments/1g6cdda/
  • u/Key-Worry5328, "PRACTO - exploitation?", r/indianmedschool, May 2025. https://www.reddit.com/r/indianmedschool/comments/1kz9iyp/
  • All accessed 20 October 2026. Anonymous and unverified.
  • Practo, "FAQs for Practo Consult (patients)" and "FAQs for Practo Prime (patients)", help.practo.com, accessed 20 October 2026.
  • Trustpilot reviews of practo.com, accessed 20 October 2026 (anonymous). https://www.trustpilot.com/review/practo.com
  • Mike Blumenthal, "Healthcare Reserve with Google Mayhem", Near Media, 25 October 2024. https://www.nearmedia.co/healthcare-reserve-with-google-mayhem/
  • Medical Dialogues, "Urologist Slams Practo for 'Unethical' Charges on Patient Inquiries", 23 November 2024. https://medicaldialogues.in/news/health/doctors/urologist-slams-practo-for-unethical-charges-on-patient-inquiries-138562

Part of our guide: Practo alternatives for doctors: subscription, lead fees, or paid per case?

For NMC-registered doctors

See patients from your phone, on your hours.

Paid per consult, weekly payouts, full visibility. You review, decide and sign every prescription. Register interest in 90 seconds. We reply within 48 hours.